Career

Can You Win Without Tricks?

Many artists bemoan the emphasis on extreme technique at competitions. But do dancers need technical bravado to place?

Judges agree that tricks can have a place in competitions—but they can also be a gamble. PC Break the Floor.

Dancers today are capable of more than ever in the way of turns, leaps and acrobatic feats. Nowhere is this more evident than at competitions, where it seems like the bar for virtuosity rises every year. Many people argue that we’ve gone too far, and competitors shouldn’t be so focused on double-digit pirouettes and flips. Dance is an art form, and there must be ways to judge a performer that have to do more with quality than quantity.

But can a dancer take home a medal without pyrotechnics? Or have expectations risen so high that judges will overlook a piece of choreography without that “wow” factor?

“It all depends on what kind of competition it is,” says Peter Stark, associate director of Boston Ballet II, head of the men’s program at Boston Ballet School and a judge at Valentina Kozlova International Ballet Competition. “If it’s for students, where we are judging potential and looking for dancers we can shape, tricks are less important. But at competitions for professionals, we need to see fully formed dancers.”

Stark says that who the judges are matters too, as you are most likely to find school directors judging student competitions and artistic directors judging professional competitions. Company directors want professionals to show the extent of their range—including their virtuosity. A certain level of technical prowess is necessary not just to win a competition, but to get a job.

But tricks can be a gamble. When performed without technique, they simply highlight the limitations of the dancer. “Too often we see technique compromised for the sake of the trick,” says Shelly Power, incoming director of the Prix de Lausanne. “Pushing through is dangerous if that foundation is not really there.” Dancers will lose points for attempting a trick they can’t pull off.

Choreographer Al Blackstone insists he’d rather see two clean pirouettes on a straight leg and strong demi-pointe than five messy spins. Still, he admits there is a place for a meaningful “wow” moment. “One beautiful trick that is emotionally driven is worth a thousand that have no context,” says Blackstone, who judges for JUMP Dance Convention. He gives the highest scores to dancers who can connect to and move an audience. “Don’t focus on what you can do, but what you can say.”

Artistry can have a virtuosity of its own, adds Stark. “The dancer can have a nuanced use of emotion and musicality that stands out,” he says. He admits that strong choreography also factors into the equation. “A dancer can be a muse to a tremendous piece of choreography,” says Stark. “A mediocre dancer can move up with a strong piece of choreography.”

A dancer’s physicality can also make a tremendous impact, as a bare-bones trick-less piece can bring forth other qualities. “If a dancer’s body is ideal, a simple piece of choreography without tricks can really emphasize the dancer’s physical presence,” adds Stark.

But if the dancer has the ability to turn and leap with bravado and polish, that’s a skill, and judges agree it will be rewarded. “Tricks push the dancer and in some instances it’s correct,” says Power.

The most successful dancers are the ones who bring it all together: an amazing dancer in a strong piece of choreography that includes some awe-inspiring technical bravado performed with exquisite artistry. “Ideally, we are looking for everything—line, form, placement and balance,” says Stark. “We want it all.” 

Jacob Jonas directed, filmed and choreographed last year's Best Overall winner. Image via Facebook

What if there was a way to get your dancing in front of the likes of Desmond Richardson, d. Sabela grimes and Vincent Paterson all at once? Just in case you needed another excuse to break out your best moves this week, the Dare to Dance in Public Film Festival is back, and Richardson, grimes and Paterson are among this year's judges.

Dancers and non-dancers alike are invited to submit short dance films to the international online festival, with one caveat: The dancing has to take place in a public space.

Keep reading... Show less
Popular

By Rick Tjia, Dance Talent Scout, Cirque du Soleil Casting

The dancers file into an audition room. They are given a number and asked to wait for registration to finish before the audition starts. At the end of the room, behind a table and a computer (and probably a number of mobile devices), there I sit, doing audio tests and updating the audition schedule as the room fills up with candidates. The dancers, more nervous than they need to be, see me, typing, perhaps teasing my colleagues, almost certainly with a coffee cup at my side.

Keep reading... Show less
AXIS Dance Company. Photo by David DeSilva, Courtesy AXIS.

Now in its 30th year, AXIS Dance Company, the pioneering physically integrated troupe in Oakland, California, is celebrating with a new artistic director, a new logo and expanded ambitions.

Keep reading... Show less
Delores Brown, photo via mobballet.org

When we're talking about the history of black dancers in ballet, three names typically pop up: Raven Wilkinson at Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo, Janet Collins at New York's Metropolitan Opera and Arthur Mitchell at New York City Ballet.

But in the 1930s through 50s, there was a largely overlooked hot spot for black ballet dancers: Philadelphia. What was going on in that city that made it such an incubator? To answer that question, we caught up with Memoirs of Blacks in Ballet founder (and frequent Dance Magazine contributor) Theresa Ruth Howard, who yesterday released her latest project, a video series called And Still They Rose: The Legacy of Black Philadelphians in Ballet.

Keep reading... Show less
Nathan Sayers

Janie Taylor didn't know if she'd ever return to the stage. But that's exactly where the former New York City Ballet principal has found herself: Nearly three years after retiring, she is performing again, as a member of L.A. Dance Project.

Taylor officially debuted with the company at its December 2016 gala in Los Angeles, then performed in Boston, via live stream from Marfa, Texas, and at New York's Joyce Theater before heading off on tour dates in France, Singapore, Dubai and beyond.

"She is wildly interesting to watch—and not conventional," says LADP artistic director Benjamin Millepied. "There are films of Suzanne Farrell dancing, where you feel like the music is coming out of her body," he says. "I think Janie has that same kind of quality."

Keep reading... Show less
Dancers & Companies

Last night was not your average Thursday at Bay Ridge Ballet in Brooklyn, New York. Studio owner and teacher Patty Foster Grado—a former Parsons Dance Company dancer—was teaching a boys class, when with only five minutes left, she heard commotion in the waiting area and someone yelled, "There's a lady giving birth in the bathroom!"

Keep reading... Show less
Dancers & Companies
PC Elena Fetisova

Where can you watch Giselle, Romeo and Juliet, The Nutcracker, Coppélia and Le Corsaire all in one place? Hint: It also has extra-buttery popcorn.

Yep, it's your local movie theater. Starting this weekend, theaters across the country will be showing Bolshoi Ballet productions of classical and contemporary story ballets.

Keep reading... Show less
Health & Body
Danielle Peazer, photo by David Salafia

When commercial dancer Danielle Peazer took on an ambassadorial role with Reebok in early 2016, she didn't realize the gig would also lead to a career shift. But while traveling with and teaching workshops for the brand, the idea for DDM (Danielle's Dance Method) Collective started to take shape.

Keep reading... Show less

Sponsored

Videos

Sponsored

mailbox

Get Dance Magazine in your inbox

Sponsored

Win It!