Can Storytelling Save Ballet?

Joffrey Ballet in Romeo and Juliet, photo by Cheryl Mann

Ballet companies are betting big on stories next season. Several major troupes announced their 2016/17 plans recently, and I've noticed one major trend: It seems like we'll be seeing more narrative work than ever before. National Ballet of Canada will present only one mixed rep program the whole season, making room for full-lengths like a new Pinocchio by Will Tuckett and John Neumeier's A Streetcar Named Desire. English National Ballet will be perform not one, but two Giselles: a new reimagining by Akram Khan in September and Mary Skeaping's classical version in January. Elsewhere, Romeo and Juliets and Cinderellas are popping up regularly.

This shift away from Balanchine-inspired abstraction and towards more narrative ballets seems to grow more prevalent every season. It's an unsurprising trend, given that stories are usually a much easier sell among audiences.

NYCB in The Most Incredible Thing, photo by Paul Kolnik

But that selling point comes with major risks. This month, two of ballet's most beloved choreographers premiered two major flops: Christopher Wheeldon's 45-minute Strapless at The Royal Ballet was called "numbing" by Clement Crisp in the Financial Times, while Justin Peck's 43-minute The Most Incredible Thing at New York City Ballet was deemed "a damp squib" by Alastair Macaulay in The New York Times. Ouch. Unfortunately, most other reviews didn't get much kinder.

Natalia Osipova in Strapless, photo by Bill Cooper

It seems unfair to compare the two ballets directly, since this was Peck's first attempt at narrative, while Wheeldon has major storytelling story successes like A Winter's Tale and Broadway's An American in Paris under his belt. But there's a similar harshness in the  takedowns of these two works (from both critics and audiences) that caught my attention. You don't typically see such severe reactions to non-narrative works. Why are people so upset by these pieces?

Part of the reason seems to be that expectations are higher for story ballets—whether it's a new story or an old one, there's a clear idea audiences can grab onto (one that often comes with nostalgic connotations), and people want to see that showcased successfully. And since stories are often major investments (American Ballet Theatre's new Sleeping Beauty by Alexei Ratmansky cost a reported $6 million, for example), there's often greater marketing efforts and more buzz.

Sarah Lamb and Steven McRae in The Winter's Tale, photo by Tristram Kenton

But not only are the stakes higher. The missteps feel less forgivable. It can be quite obvious what's not working, and audiences feel cheated if the plot isn't presented in a way that's fulfilling. They want a satisfying beginning, middle and end, as well as characters they can relate to. In plotless works, viewers might not pick up on the choreographer's intention, but they can still appreciate the movement. With stories, on the other hand, you feel lost if you don't "get it." A beautiful movement quality isn't enough to make up for a weak climax. Yet few choreographers are taught skills like how to flesh out characters, convey plot twists through dance and build momentum in a storyline.

If companies are looking for new hits, they need to give their choreographers access to other artists and mentors who can teach them those tools. And they have to be willing to offer one other important resource: time. Novelists can spend years on a single book. We can't expect choreographers to produce nuanced, in-depth stories when they're churning out something new every three months. I know, few companies have the money to pay for generous creation periods. But if they're betting on these ballets to become their next big hits, it's worth doubling down on their investment to help them succeed.

 

Get more Dance Magazine.

Broadway
The "Merde" bag. Courtesy Scenery

Jennifer Kahn knew the theater industry could do better. As a professional stage manager for 17 years she worked on regional, off-Broadway and Broadway shows. Nearly each time a show closed, something unsettling happened: "I would watch them throw away our shows. All of the beautiful artwork by my friends in the paint shop would go in the trash." The elaborate backdrops? Gone.

But she had an idea: What if the material used in the backdrops and legs could be upcycled into something new? And what if theater lovers could literally keep a piece of a beloved show?

Keep reading... Show less
Sponsored by Harlequin Floors
Left: Hurricane Harvey damage in Houston Ballet's Dance Lab; Courtesy Harlequin. Right: The Dance Lab pre-Harvey; Nic Lehoux, Courtesy Houston Ballet.

"The show must go on" may be a platitude we use to get through everything from costume malfunctions to stormy moods. But when it came to overcoming a literal hurricane, Houston Ballet was buoyed by this mantra to go from devastated to dancing in a matter of weeks—with the help of Harlequin Floors, Houston Ballet's longstanding partner who sprang into action to build new floors in record time.

Keep reading... Show less
News
Photo by Gabriel Davalos, Courtesy Valdés

For decades the name Alicia Alonso has been virtually synonymous with Ballet Nacional de Cuba, the company she co-founded in Havana in 1948. Alonso died on October 17, just shy of what would have been her 99th birthday. In recent years, she had stepped back from day-to-day decision-making in the company. As if preparing for the future, in January, the company's leading ballerina, 42-year-old Viengsay Valdés, was named deputy director, a job that seems to encompass most of the responsibilities of a traditional director. Now, presumably, she will step into her new role as director of the company. Her debut as curator of the repertory comes in November, when the troupe will perform three mixed bills selected by her at the Gran Teatro de la Habana Alicia Alonso. The following has been translated from a conversation conducted in Spanish, Valdés' native tongue.

Keep reading... Show less
Health & Body
Sara Mearns in the gym. Photo by Kyle Froman.

New York City Ballet principal Sara Mearns wasn't sure she was strong enough. A ballerina who has danced many demanding full-length and contemporary roles, she was about to push herself physically more than she thought was possible.

"I said, 'I can't. My body won't,' " she says. "He told me, 'Yes, it will.' "

She wasn't working with a ballet coach, but with personal trainer Joel Prouty, who was asking her to do squats with a heavier barbell than she'd ever used.

Keep reading... Show less

mailbox

Get Dance Magazine in your inbox