Why Some Dancers Are Giving “Hiplet” Serious Side Eye

April 27, 2017

is sweeping the nation. Between TedX, Refinery29, Desigual campaigns, Anna Wintour’s #madeforher fundraiser and the plethora of morning show spots, the hybrid dance craze—known for its sassy runway-style walks on pointe and crab-like bent-knee jazzy chassés—has gone viral.

Hiplet is the brain child of Homer Hans Bryant, a former Dance Theatre of Harlem principal who, in 1981, founded Chicago Multi-Cultural Dance Center (then called Bryant Ballet), aka the studio where young Sasha and Malia Obama studied before moving to the White House. Bryant started putting hip hop movement on pointe in 1994 with a piece he choreographed for his students, called The Rap Ballet. That evolved into what became hiplet (a portmanteau of hip hop and ballet), which is now a regular class at his school.

But his curious blend of hip hop sur la pointe has proven to be quite provocative. Some see the blending of the urban and European dance vernaculars as a positive by-product of the black ballerina movement. For me and many others, it sets our teeth on edge.

Why such strong reactions? As a former ballet dancer, and current ballet educator, I’ve attempted to break down why it evokes such icky feelings.

1.The Lack of Ballet Technique

Unlike hiplet, Robert Garland’s Return blends ballet with social dance in a way that shows off the dancers’ virtuosic technique

Most troublesome for me is the fact that the hiplet ladies have so little ballet technique. To be fair, the three older dancers who are typically featured in the group numbers have beautiful feet and show flashes of solid ballet training. But many of the rest are unable to fully get on their box. It’s cringe-worthy and dangerous.

Perhaps if the hiplet dancers exhibited the duality of striking beautiful first arabesque lines in addition to being able to “break it down,” there might be less vitriol. For example, Robert Garland’s Return set to music by Aretha Franklin and James Brown melds ballet and social dance quite well by highlighting the adroit ballet technique and versatility of Dance Theatre of Harlem’s dancers.

But most of the hiplet dancers can’t hit those ballet lines, and as a result, the technique is more akin to a toe tapping in a vaudevillian sideshow.

Which is weird, because Bryant is a fantastic ballet teacher, known for his bootcamp-like approach to ballet training. He’s famous for employing tactics like non-stop “aerobic” barres, from pliés to battements with no breaks; as you turn from the left side to the right he’ll bark out the next combination. I know because I was his student at a DTH summer intensive at age 13. He was inspiring and effective, well-versed in technique, and was a stickler for strength, stamina and precision.

So for people who have danced and trained (in the traditional capacity) with Bryant, hiplet leaves many of us asking the question, “What happened?” Bryant is finally getting some of the recognition that he is due. It’s unfortunate is it not for what he is truly gifted at: training technically proficient ballet dancers.

2.It’s Neither Hip(Hop) nor (Bal)Let

Is Memphis Jookin more balletic than hiplet? Lil Buck uses elements of pointe work in his movement

Hiplet purports to be a blend of hip hop and ballet, but the lack of authentic representation of either genre is another reason some of us are giving it a hard side-eye. The only aspects of ballet would be the use of pointe shoes and some questionably-executed basic ballet vocabulary. And the technique doesn’t draw from real hip hop roots, either. The foundational techniques of hip hop are popping, locking and breaking, although Jookin, a Memphis-born derivative (also known as the “Gangsta walk”), sometimes resembles ballet with its elements of gliding and toe work. But hiplet is more of a mash-up of many styles of West African, Horton, jazz, dance hall and social dance.

3.It Undercuts Legit Advances for Black Dancers

Just when black ballerinas like Michaela DePrince are climbing the ranks in major companies, hiplet presents a caricature of “blacks doing ballet.” Photo by Angela Sterling, courtesy Dutch National Ballet

For ballet dancers of color, hiplet is something of an embarrassment. Just when artistic directors are finally taking the need for diversity seriously, and a few black ballerinas are climbing the ranks in major companies, there is hiplet. Just when we can proudly and enthusiastically hashtag #blackballerinas, #blackelegance #browngirlsdoballet and mean it, when we feel like we are the Jeffersons, movin’ on up, hiplet is the ghettoization of blacks doing “ballet.” Not because it blends African American urban social dance and a European court social dance, but because it does it crudely, without sophistication and hence becomes a mockery of our honest efforts to excel at the latter while not honoring the brilliance of the former.

It is not coincidental that just as we have numerous examples of black ballet excellence, a caricaturized image of “blacks doing ballet” becomes the rage. There has always been a cultural counterbalance that happens when African Americans start to make progress. When movies or televisions shows featuring positive black characters and stories are finally produced, there is always what feels like a backlash, where we are presented with versions of ourselves that are laughable or belittling. It feels like tiny weights have been tethered to our wings just as we think we are about to soar.

4.It Feels Immature and Opportunistic

If a 20-something dance student snapping footage of friends fooling around in a studio complete with the “YASSSSSES” and “WERKS” in the background was responsible for hiplet, people could better understand it, because it feels immature, impromptu, faddish. When you learn that it is the product of a 67-year-old man, it seems…odd. It feels opportunistic, a phenomenon that is riding the wave of conversations about blacks in ballet straight to the bank. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but you have to ask, “At what cost?” More than ever, images create our reality. Does hiplet help or hurt?

Who knows how long hiplet will be on our radar. I am sure that these young ladies are having wonderful experiences and seeing aspects of the world that they never thought possible. That in and of itself is a positive.

But it is hard to imagine these students growing up become hiplet teachers, or mothers being willing to spend upwards of $80 a pop for pointe shoes for daughters to learn to Dougie on in the long-term. But stranger things have happened.

For now, in old-school fashion, I’ll give a nod to Naughty by Nature and say, “Hip hop hiplet, hey, no.”